Rookie running backs continue to make a significant impact in fantasy football. Last year, Bucky Irving emerged as one of the best value picks in both redraft and dynasty leagues. In 2024, Bijan Robinson finished as the RB8 and Jahmyr Gibbs as the RB9. The year prior, De’Von Achane was a league-winner.

With fewer running backs playing into their 30s, teams are quicker to cycle through backs, often relying on rookies to fill starting roles. Only the elite talents secure a second contract, thereby increasing opportunities for younger players. Even if rookies don’t start immediately, the physical toll of the position and frequent injuries often create openings. That’s especially exciting in a year with a running back class that rivals 2017 as the best I’ve ever evaluated.

In this article, I’ll cover each rookie running back selected within the top 130 picks of the 2025 NFL Draft. While running backs don’t need high draft capital to be valuable, it certainly helps secure early playing time. It is worth noting that with such a terrific draft class, draft capital may be slightly skewed this year: running backs that went on Day 3 in 2025 may have easily been 2nd round picks last year. There are also several intriguing prospects taken outside these parameters, but they won’t be the focus here.

To evaluate each back, I’ll reference RotoViz’s Prospect Box Score Scout, which generates comparable players based on statistical profiles. If you don’t already subscribe to RotoViz, we highly recommend them — they’re the best in evidence-based fantasy football content.

Ashton Jeanty, 6th Overall, Oakland Raiders

One of the most hyped prospects in this class, Ashton Jeanty, became the highest-drafted running back since Saquon Barkley in 2018.

As a freshman, Jeanty contributed, but he broke out in his sophomore season with 1,920 total yards and 19 touchdowns. He followed that up with a jaw-dropping junior year: 2,739 total yards and 30 touchdowns.

As a sophomore, Jeanty nearly led his team in receptions (47 to 43). By 2024, he carried the ball a staggering 374 times — over 317 more carries than any of his teammates — and almost matched his starting quarterback in total attempts (396 passes). His workload was historic.

As Shawn Siegele noted, Jeanty’s 84 broken tackles in 2024 were the most in the past five years — 28 more than his already-elite 2023 mark, which ranked third in that span. He also led all backs in yards after contact over that five-year window.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Ashton Jeanty6119.4522601230.640.36211
36Bijan Robinson8109.941.941578190.60.324.46215
30Christian McCaffrey81062.681603370.580.364.48202
17Ezekiel Elliott4113.171.661821270.620.314.47225
14Darren McFadden4120.761.211830210.480.324.33211
14Donald Brown27105.561.332083210.620.364.46210
12Knowshon Moreno12105.152.041400330.640.324.5217
6Melvin Gordon15119.880.542587190.410.274.52215
6Jonathan Stewart1382.031.371722220.520.234.46235
5Rashard Mendenhall2372.541.691681340.510.294.41225
4Trent Richardson382.371.791679290.410.244.48228

Column Key

Sim refers to the sim score for how similar each comparable player is. RuYPG is the average per game for each rusher’s career. RecPG is the per-game receptions for each player’s career. RuYds and Rec represent rush yards and receptions for each player’s final season. RuYMS refers to the rushing yards market share. TYms refers to each player’s market share of total yards.

With top comparable players like Bijan Robinson and Christian McCaffrey, Jeanty enters the NFL with elite company. Running backs are rarely drafted this early without a strong profile, and Jeanty clearly earned the investment.

Raiders offensive coordinator Chip Kelly stated, “Ashton is as talented a back as I’ve seen… His ability to sustain runs after contact is a rare quality.” Fantasy managers are already treating Jeanty as a first-round pick in redraft formats — and rightfully so.

Omarion Hampton, 22nd Overall, Los Angeles Chargers

Hampton was the second running back selected in the draft, and earning first-round capital at the position is no small feat in today’s NFL. He was active early in his college career, but took a major step forward as a sophomore, posting consecutive seasons with an 80%+ dominator rating. In his junior year, he added 373 receiving yards on 38 catches, showcasing his ability as a receiver.

At 221 pounds, Hampton ran a 4.46 forty, giving him a 94th percentile speed score. He also posted a 91st percentile burst score — elite athleticism for his size.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Omarion Hampton2296.351.971660380.670.274.46221
93Breece Hall36109.222.281462360.790.324.39217
86Dalvin Cook41117.472.081765330.70.334.49210
76Cam Akers5279.831.921144300.630.254.47217
65Jonathan Stewart1382.031.371722220.520.234.46235
63Knowshon Moreno12105.152.041400330.640.324.5217
58Travis Etienne2590.041.85914480.50.244.45215
55J.K. Dobbins55106.171.692003230.560.25209
51Donald Brown27105.561.332083210.620.364.46210
40Rashard Mendenhall2372.541.691681340.510.294.41225
36Duke Johnson Jr.77106.642.091652380.60.294.54207

With top comps like Breece Hall and Dalvin Cook, Hampton has an exciting profile. On film, he’s reminiscent of DeMarco Murray — a bigger, upright running back with workhorse production. Given Najee Harris’ decline, it’s hard to imagine Hampton staying on the bench for long.

Chargers coach Jim Harbaugh described his plan to use Hampton and Harris as a “1-2 punch,” but by season’s end, expect Hampton to be leading the backfield.

Quinshon Judkins, 36th Overall, Cleveland Browns

It was a surprise to see Judkins selected over TreVeyon Henderson, who went just two picks later. After transferring to Ohio State from Ole Miss, Judkins split the backfield with Henderson and played the David Montgomery role to Henderson’s Jahmyr Gibbs.

Judkins broke out at Ole Miss as an 18-year-old freshman, again serving as a workhorse in his sophomore year, though his efficiency dipped. As a junior, Judkins transferred to Ohio State. He averaged 5.7 yards per touch compared to Henderson’s 7.6. His efficiency in college paints a troubling picture. Judkins’ ability to force missed tacklers and have an impact in the passing game is also underwhelming. To use a baseball term, he looks like an “innings eater.”

Still, Judkins is an impressive athlete, running a 4.48 forty at 221 lbs with a 94th percentile burst score. At just 21 years old with strong early production, there’s still hope.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Quinshon Judkins3690.121.41060220.540.234.48221
73Eddie Lacy6172.791.061322220.340.194.55231
59T.J. Yeldon3685.181.18979150.430.224.61226
51Cam Akers5279.831.921144300.630.254.47217
44Mark Ingram2883.621.54875210.430.254.62215
44Glen Coffee7461.971.241383160.370.24.5209
43Jeremy Hill55981.181401180.50.264.56233
40David Montgomery7379.051.921216220.620.254.63222
27Derrius Guice5990.410.941251180.390.234.49224
27Justice Hill11398.311.36930130.590.214.4198
22Jeremy Langford106105.961.391522110.540.264.42208

The concern? His comps include Eddie Lacy, T.J. Yeldon, Cam Akers, Mark Ingram, and David Montgomery — solid backs, but rarely league-winners. Judkins may prove useful, but he’s unlikely to be explosive enough to become a long-term fantasy difference-maker.

TreVeyon Henderson, 38th Overall, New England Patriots

The Patriots finally added explosiveness to their offense with the selection of TreVeyon Henderson. He burst onto the scene as a freshman at Ohio State, racking up 1,560 yards and 19 touchdowns on just 210 touches. After an injury-plagued sophomore and junior campaign, Henderson bounced back as a senior, outperforming Judkins on fewer touches.

As Scott Barrett noted, Henderson averaged 7.60 yards per touch in 2024 — the highest mark of any Power Conference RB (minimum 135 carries) in the last four years.

At the combine, Henderson ran a 4.43 forty (92nd percentile) and recorded a 91st percentile burst score. He’s dynamic and efficient — but the red flag is his usage. Since his freshman season, he has never truly dominated backfield touches, possibly due to his size (202 lbs.) or the depth of the Buckeyes’ offense.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100TreVeyon Henderson3880.021.641016270.490.214.43202
89Isaiah Pead5078.292.071259390.610.254.39197
89Javonte Williams3576.571.671140250.370.194.55212
86Jonathon Brooks46871.651139250.420.22216
75Ben Tate5875.481.21362200.430.234.34220
72Mark Ingram2883.621.54875210.430.254.62215
66Kerryon Johnson4369.281.531391240.330.2213
66Doug Martin3170.021.371299280.390.184.46223
65Michael Carter10777.341.861245250.420.24.5201
63Blake Corum8382.821.241245160.460.234.53205
63Najee Harris2475.351.571466430.420.18

His comps aren’t overly exciting, likely a result of his market share concerns. Still, Patriots GM Eliot Wolf said the team views him as “a three-down back and a really good compliment.” With his explosiveness, Henderson should quickly eat into Rhamondre Stevenson’s workload.

If his freshman year is indicative of his ceiling, Henderson could have an immediate impact. I’ve projected him for a larger workload than many expect.

RJ Harvey, 60th Overall, Denver Broncos

Harvey’s path to the NFL was unorthodox. He began his career at Virginia as a redshirt quarterback before transferring to UCF. After missing his second season with an ACL tear, he finally broke out as a junior with a 76% dominator rating. In his final year, Harvey totaled 1,844 yards and 25 touchdowns while averaging 6.8 yards per carry — the best mark in the Big 12. Over his last three seasons, he also caught 61 passes for 720 yards.

While Harvey’s production is impressive, he’s already 24 years old, which is a concern for dynasty formats. That said, he should be pro-ready. At 205 lbs, he ran a 4.4 forty and tested well in the leaping drills.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100RJ Harvey6097.231.561577200.540.284.4205
99Jamaal Charles7387.581.291619170.570.264.38200
97Kendall Hunter11590.891.371548200.490.234.46199
97Ameer Abdullah5488.231.41611220.490.274.6205
93Blake Corum8382.821.241245160.460.234.53205
93J.K. Dobbins55106.171.692003230.560.25209
89Ben Tate5875.481.21362200.430.234.34220
88Tyjae Spears8188.331.421581220.50.26201
80Darrell Henderson7093.291.661909190.430.224.49208
79Johnathan Franklin12583.081.091734330.580.264.49205
77Royce Freeman71110.221.551475140.50.264.54229

The comps include Jamaal Charles — the crown jewel — though most of the others didn’t reach similar heights. Regardless, Harvey may have landed in the most favorable spot of any rookie. Javonte Williams is gone, and Jaleel McLaughlin struggled to earn consistent touches. Sean Payton has a history of targeting running backs in the passing game, and Harvey is expected to step in right away. He has a real shot to become Denver’s every-down back.

Kaleb Johnson, 83rd Overall, Pittsburgh Steelers

Kaleb Johnson showed flashes early, registering a 50% dominator rating as a freshman. He struggled as a sophomore while dealing with an ankle injury: he rushed for a mere 3.96 YPC and registered just a 40% dominator rating. Across his first two seasons, he recorded just seven receptions. As a junior, he had a fantastic season, reaching an 83% dominator rating while carrying the ball 240 times for 1,537 yards and 21 touchdowns. He even chipped in 22 receptions for 188 yards.

At 224 lbs, Johnson ran a 4.57 forty, producing a respectable 75th percentile speed score — but his 1.62-second 10-yard split was the slowest among RBs in the past four years.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Kaleb Johnson8379.40.831537220.560.314.57224
99Mikel Leshoure5782.481.191697170.530.284.56227
88Zack Moss8690.291.471416280.550.274.65223
87Carlos Hyde5784.160.891521160.490.264.62230
74Alex Collins17197.450.711577130.470.254.59217
72Tank Bigsby8882.941.77970300.570.274.56210
72Ameer Abdullah5488.231.41611220.490.274.6205
70Delone Carter11975.710.68123380.570.274.54222
70Stevan Ridley7364.50.771147110.40.214.65225
69LeVeon Bell4883.651.951793320.540.254.6230
68Jeremy Hill55981.181401180.50.264.56233

With comps like Zack Moss, Carlos Hyde, and Stevan Ridley, Johnson profiles as a between-the-tackles grinder. He’s unlikely to see much third-down work, especially with Jaylen Warren — one of the league’s best pass blockers — already on the roster. Johnson may handle early-down carries, but his fantasy upside appears limited on an offense that should struggle to score touchdowns.

Bhayshul Tuten, 104th Overall, Jacksonville Jaguars

Tuten began his college career at North Carolina A&T, where he dominated weaker competition with a 75% dominator rating, rushing for 1,363 yards and catching 31 passes. He then transferred to Virginia Tech and continued to shine, posting an 81% dominator rating as a sophomore and a 94% mark as a junior.

Scott Barrett highlighted that Tuten led all Power Conference RBs in two key advanced metrics: career yards after contact per attempt (4.08) and missed tackles forced per touch (0.35).

Tuten is also a freakish athlete — at 206 lbs, he ran a 4.32 forty and recorded a 97th percentile burst score.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Bhayshul Tuten10496.692.291158220.690.344.32206
92Marlon Mack143100.251.811187280.660.324.5213
89Steve Slaton89112.091.861051260.60.414.45197
75Isaiah Spiller12385.662.111012250.550.27217
66Jamaal Charles7387.581.291619170.570.264.38200
63Will Shipley12776.142.36827310.540.26206
59Paul Perkins14989.442.051343300.550.254.54208
59Cam Akers5279.831.921144300.630.254.47217
58Tank Bigsby8882.941.77970300.570.274.56210
58Javon Ringer17397.482.141637280.60.284.5205
58Rasheen Ali16597.792.591140280.680.29206

Despite being a fourth-round pick, Tuten looks capable of overtaking Jacksonville’s underperforming backfield. A little deeper on the comparable player list was De’Von Achane, who looks quite similar.

PlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
Bhayshul Tuten10496.692.291158220.690.344.32206
Devon Achane8484.822.321102360.520.284.32188

He may not have De’Von Achane’s elite receiving skillset, but his physical profile is similar — just as fast, but heavier. Tuten could emerge as a breakout rookie – maybe fumbles in practice can keep his ADP in check?

Cam Skattebo, 105th Overall, New York Giants

Skattebo began his career at Sacramento State, where he broke out in his sophomore season with over 1,500 rushing yards and 30 receptions — averaging an impressive 7.26 yards per carry. After transferring to Arizona State, he posted an excellent 79% dominator rating in his junior season. His senior year was nothing short of phenomenal: 1,715 rushing yards, 45 receptions for 605 yards, and 24 touchdowns.

His 1,144 yards after contact in 2024 were the most by any Power Conference running back in the last five years. He also forced 115 missed tackles — the most ever charted in a single season by PFF College.

Despite his incredible production, Skattebo didn’t run at the combine due to a reported injury and clocked a disappointing 4.65 at his Pro Day. This likely hurt his draft position. That said, he posted excellent jumping numbers at the combine, earning an 89th percentile burst score.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Cameron Skattebo105104.162.681715450.690.36219
47James Starks19387.223.531333520.70.344.5218
42Aaron Jones182117.542.031773280.670.44.56208
37Devontae Booker136120.573.481261370.810.424.56219
34Justin Jackson251106.672.391311440.690.344.52199
34Jeremy McNichols16294.263.031709370.50.264.49214
30Tank Bigsby8882.941.77970300.570.274.56210
28Duke Johnson Jr.77106.642.091652380.60.294.54207
28LeVeon Bell4883.651.951793320.540.254.6230
27Jay Ajayi14999.891.921823500.60.284.57221
26Rachaad White9195.43.41011430.560.384.48214

Comps like Aaron Jones and Le’Veon Bell suggest Skattebo is a versatile back with all-around skills. While his 40-time may scare some, I prioritize production, and Skattebo has it in spades. He’s the kind of player I want to be overweight on in drafts.

Trevor Etienne, 114th Overall, Carolina Panthers

Trevor Etienne started at Florida, posting a 28% dominator rating as a true freshman. In his sophomore year, he became more involved as a receiver, with 21 catches for 172 yards. He transferred to Georgia as a junior, where he shared the backfield with Nate Frazier but led the team’s running backs in receptions with 32.

At 198 lbs, Etienne ran a 4.42 forty and profiles as a capable third-down back at the next level.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Trevor Etienne11461.211.82609320.440.194.42198
96Mike Goodson11154.562.5406370.430.244.43208
95John Kelly17658.261.59778370.410.21216
89Cyrus Gray18267.312.11045310.470.24.4206
81Devonta Freeman10360.951.271016220.370.174.58206
81Will Shipley12776.142.36827310.540.26206
80Travis Homer20471.431.32985190.480.244.48201
77Bryce Love11278.761736200.430.23200
77Chris Thompson15448.221.25687210.330.154.42192
76Mike Weber21870.421.42954210.420.184.47211
74Mike Davis12665.951.89982320.470.224.61217

Chris Thompson seems like the perfect comp for Etienne, but Etienne appears to be the better rusher. With Jonathan Brooks expected to miss the season, Etienne looks well-positioned to take over Carolina’s passing-down work.

Woody Marks, 116th Overall, Houston Texans

Jo’Quavious “Woody” Marks entered college as a receiving specialist, catching 60 passes as a true freshman at Mississippi State and an eye-popping 83 the following year. Despite a 57% dominator rating as a sophomore, he averaged just 3.92 yards per carry. In his fifth year, as a 24-year-old, he transferred to USC, where he improved as a rusher while still catching 47 passes.

Marks has an elite receiving profile, but his athleticism is underwhelming. He ran a 4.54 forty at 207 lbs and didn’t test well in the jumping drills.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Joquavious Marks11652.914.581133470.540.24.54207
49Charles Sims72.194.231095450.510.22
30Shannon Woods55.13.73716360.530.16
27Josh Ferguson56.223.65708370.480.254.48198
26DeAndre Washington14372.572.641492410.530.194.49204
21Evan Hull17670.942.74913550.530.34.47209
20Baron Batch58.163.26816320.490.17
18Jamal Morrow36.634.12522600.40.15
18Ulonzo Gilliam98.84.41191500.60.29
16Ontario Sneed60.913.34548320.620.25
16Ronnie Rivers65.712.88788340.510.234.6195

His closest comps are mostly undrafted receiving specialists. He’s unlikely to ever become a lead back, but he could carve out a role as a passing-down contributor. If the Texans deploy him creatively, Marks might return value in deeper PPR formats — but his upside is limited.

Jarquez Hunter, 117th Overall, Los Angeles Rams

A four-year player at Auburn, Hunter flashed early, averaging 6.66 yards per carry on 89 attempts as a freshman. He posted a 59% dominator rating as a sophomore. Hunter saved his best for last as a senior with 1,201 rushing yards, 21 receptions, and a 77% dominator rating. He led the SEC in yards per carry and broke 40 tackles. Per Rotoworld, he averaged 3.96 yards after contact per attempt and forced a missed tackle on over 30% of his carries.

At the NFL Combine, Hunter ran a 4.44 forty at 204 lbs.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Jarquez Hunter11768.941.391201210.490.234.44204
100Bilal Powell12661.531.181405180.40.194.51207
99Michael Carter10777.341.861245250.420.24.5201
97Blake Corum8382.821.241245160.460.234.53205
97Darrynton Evans9377.921.051479210.380.224.41203
96Travis Homer20471.431.32985190.480.244.48201
95Tyjae Spears8188.331.421581220.50.26201
95Elijah Mitchell19477.61.17878160.360.214.38201
94Israel Abanikanda14372.571.271431120.50.2216
94Cyrus Gray18267.312.11045310.470.24.4206
91Andre Ellington18770.121.21081140.460.24.61199

The comparable players list includes some interesting names but no big hits. Hunter isn’t a big back and wasn’t a dominant receiver in college, but his advanced rushing metrics were excellent. After the Rams traded up to draft him, he should project ahead of Blake Corum for the No. 2 role behind Kyren Williams.

Dylan Sampson, 126th Overall, Cleveland Browns

Sampson played sparingly as a freshman at Tennessee but was extremely efficient (6.84 YPC). As a sophomore, he took control of the backfield, posting a 59% dominator rating. He followed it up with an excellent junior season: 1,491 rushing yards on 258 carries and 22 touchdowns.

Though he didn’t run at the combine, Sampson reportedly ran a 4.42 forty at his Pro Day. He checks in at 200 lbs.

SimPlayerDraftRuYPGRecPGRuYdsRecRuYMSTymsFortyWT
100Dylan Sampson12675.481.211491200.390.19200
99Bilal Powell12661.531.181405180.40.194.51207
98Glen Coffee7461.971.241383160.370.24.5209
97Darrynton Evans9377.921.051479210.380.224.41203
95Israel Abanikanda14372.571.271431120.50.2216
94Devonta Freeman10360.951.271016220.370.174.58206
93Mike Weber21870.421.42954210.420.184.47211
92Travis Homer20471.431.32985190.480.244.48201
88Tyjae Spears8188.331.421581220.50.26201
83Cameron Artis-Payne17485.310.541608130.380.224.53212
80Jeremy Langford106105.961.391522110.540.264.42208

Sampson’s comps aren’t elite, but his production may be undersold because of the depth of this class. The landing spot is less than ideal, as he joins a Browns backfield that already features fellow rookie Quinshon Judkins. However, GM Andrew Berry said Sampson has “untapped potential in the passing game.” He’ll likely be competing to earn passing down work over Jerome Ford.